Allison Kilkenny: Unreported

Audio: Military Analysts Laud "The Leader" Rumsfeld

Posted in media, politics by allisonkilkenny on May 9, 2008

Source: Paul Kiel, Talking Points Memo

Last month, The New York Times published its front-page exposé of the Pentagon’s strategy of using military analysts. The retired officers who frequently appeared on TV were the ideal vehicle to broadcast the administration’s message on the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. “Message force multipliers,” Pentagon officials called them.

Well, earlier this week, the Pentagon released all of the documents that had been turned over to the Times. It is a staggering load. But most immediately intriguing is audio of some of the briefings at the Pentagon, including two featuring Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld.

The audio we’ve excerpted here comes from a meeting on April 18, 2006. It was an emergency meeting called because earlier in the month, several retired generals had hit the airwaves demanding that Rumsfeld resign. 17 analysts attended the briefing, which featured Rumsfeld and then-Chairman of the Joint Chiefs Peter Pace. It was a remarkable display of servility, with one analyst at one point proclaiming that Rumsfeld need to get out there on the “offense,” because “we’d love to be following our leader, as indeed you are. You are the leader. You are our guy.”

Audio behind the cut…

Another analyst chimed in to the effect that, though PsyOps or “brainwashing” are dirty words, it was necessary to get out there on offense. “You know what they call PsyOps today, they call those public relations firms,” another said approvingly. Finally, Rumsfeld had to throw up his hands: “You people should be taking notes. I’m taking all the notes!” It sure was an eager group.

A transcript is available here (pdf) for those who want to follow along at home. The excerpt above begins at the bottom of page 18. It cuts at one point to the top of page 20. The full audio of the briefing is here (wav).

Unfortunately, the transcript does not name the analysts when they speak (it just says “Question”), meaning that it is not easily possible to figure out which of them said what. A list of the participants, however, is here.

The Times reported that the meeting was a rousing success for the Pentagon:

The meeting ended and Mr. Rumsfeld, appearing pleased and relaxed, took the entire group into a small study and showed off treasured keepsakes from his life, several analysts recalled.

Soon after, analysts hit the airwaves. The Omnitec monitoring reports, circulated to more than 80 officials, confirmed that analysts repeated many of the Pentagon’s talking points: that Mr. Rumsfeld consulted “frequently and sufficiently” with his generals; that he was not “overly concerned” with the criticisms; that the meeting focused “on more important topics at hand,” including the next milestone in Iraq, the formation of a new government.

Omnitec Solutions was the private contractor that was paid “hundreds of thousands of dollars to scour databases for any trace of the analysts.” The company “evaluated their appearances using the same tools as corporate branding experts.”

Update: The Politico reports on the “deafening silence” created by the networks failure to run with the Times’ story.

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. hANOVER fIST said, on May 9, 2008 at 1:36 am

    Until the average American can watch stupid reality TV while drinking their beer, WE WILL NOT SEE ANY REAL CHANGE.

    Listen to the radio shows…the left-wing shows are preaching to the choir – we, for the most part, already know what’s going on, and when something new is mentioned, as incredulous as it is…it’s expected. The people who should pay attention can’t stand the constant fact-chucking that left-wing shows perform.

    Now…the right-wing shows are a masterpiece! They LIE…CONSTANTLY. They could care less about getting facts right – they will mouth a few lies, their sycophants will go on the air and cement the point in the heads of the empty-heads / dittoheads / etc., until it is the new talking point.

    Tell your neighbor that we have government agents lying to you on TV?

    “Well, they’re trying to protect the country…and what are you doing, you commie pinko?”

    “huh? What? I’m just telling …”

    “George Dubya Bush is a Christian, and a reg’lur guy…I could have beers with ‘im…John kerry is a stuck-up stiff!”

    “But…but…” – please! You can’t waste your energy with this…I say…LET’S ADOPT THEIR METHODS!

    Fudge the story just a tad…don’t go too wild with the allegation…but most importantly…KEEP IT SIMPLE, STUPID!

    And real short.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: